Quantcast
breaking news

Why Can't Illinois Be More Like Wisconsin?

By: Matt Mershon
Updated: January 15, 2013
watch video

ROCKFORD - A potential budget surplus is in the cards for the state of Wisconsin, according to Governor Walker's State of the State Address, Tuesday night.  Even though Wisconsin is Illinois' neighbor to the north, the budget surplus hasn't made its way to the Prairie State.  Political analysts say a wide difference in political ideology is why Wisconsin could get their ducks in a row and why Illinois still has its problems.

 

That balanced budget didn't come without protest in Wisconsin.  Protests erupted because of Governor Scott Walker's extremely conservative measures to help curtail spending and fix the budget deficit.

 

"About $800 million was cut in education in Wisconsin and that's jut not going to happen in Illinois," said P.S. Ruckman, political analyst.

 

"The teachers unions just have much more power here."

 

Ruckman comments that any union in Illinois has more arguing power than in Wisconsin, especially after Governor Walker rid collective-bargaining rights for unions in the Badger State.  Wisconsin public employee benefits were slashed too, and Ruckman says that even republicans in the Prairie State would be against that.

 

"Local republicans, they claim to be fiscal conservatives and tax-payer protectors, but they spend and allocate money by the millions from the state which is bankrupt," said Ruckman.

 

But in Wisconsin they are "real" fiscal conservatives.  Georgia Duerst-Lahti, political science professor at Beloit College, says that plays to a republican governor's advantage.

 

"Governor Walker has a really conservative leadership and majority in the senate and a really conservative leadership and majority in the state assembly," said Duerst-Lahti.

 

"He's got a clean sweep," comments Duerst-Lahti, "he can do whatever he wants right now."

 

But could drastically conservative measures even fix Illinois' budget crisis?  Both Duerst-Lahti and Ruckman say Wisconsin didn't have as big of a problem that Illinois does now.

 

"Wisconsin didn't have a pension problem," said Duerst-Lahti.  "So if you're factoring that in to what you're going off of, you're starting out in a very different place."

 

And Ruckman says this supposed budget surplus is projected and not certain.  For all we know, Wisconsin could be in a budget deficit as well.

 

"These kinds of projections are as many times as much an advertisement as they are facts and you can't push that entirely aside," said Ruckman.

 

Both analysts say Illinois and Wisconsin, aside from the big cities, are predominantly "red" states.  Milwaukee would be most comparable to Chicago, and it doesn't nearly have the population power that Chicago has.  That's why the democrats in Madison don't have as big a pull.

 

Comments

Readers Feel...

hello
 
 
 
 
 
©1998 - 2013 Mystateline.com
Nexstar Broadcasting, Inc.
All Rights Reserved